Eliminate -- Mike Lubinski

Season 1
Brittany Petros
Jamie Kern

Season 2
Autumn Daly
Nicole Nilson

Season 3
Chiara Berti
Jason Guy
Lori Olsen

Season 4
Dana Varela
Jee Choe

Season 5
Adria Klein
Natalie Carroll

Season 6
James Rhine
Rachel Plencner

Season 8
Kail Harbick

Season 9
Alex Coladonato
Amanda Hansen
Sheila Kennedy

Season 10
Memphis Garrett

Season 11
Michele Noonan

Season 12
Andrew Gordon
Annie Whittington
Kathy Hillis
Lane Elenburg
Monet Stunson